Your Water Deductible Went Up. Here Is What to Do Before the Next Renewal.

The renewal letter arrives, the water deductible has jumped, and the council has about eight weeks to decide what to tell the owners. This is the sequence that tends to work.

1. Get the loss history in writing

Before anything else, ask your broker for the building’s claims history — dates, amounts, causes, and which ones were water. You need this for two reasons: it tells you whether you have a plumbing problem or a bad-luck problem, and it is the first thing any insurer will ask for if you go to market.

If three of the last four claims came from the same riser or the same fixture type, you have a specific, fixable problem. That is a much better story to take to a renewal than a general commitment to be more careful.

2. Ask the broker the conditional question

Most councils ask "can we get the deductible down?" The more productive version is:

What would our terms look like at renewal if we had certified flow-based leak detection and automatic shutoff on the common risers, with documentation you can verify?

This forces a specific answer. Some insurers will name a number. Some will say it affects appetite rather than price — meaning it changes whether they will quote at all, which matters more in a hard market. Either answer is useful, and both are better than a general assurance that prevention "helps."

Get it in writing if you can. It is the single most persuasive document you can put in front of owners.

3. Separate the two funding conversations

Full suite-by-suite coverage and common-area-first coverage are different numbers, and they go to owners differently.

Common risers, mechanical rooms, and amenity spaces are shared assets. Protecting them is ordinary maintenance of common property, and in most buildings that is a contingency or operating conversation — no suite access required, no owner opt-in to coordinate.

Suite-level coverage is a bigger number and touches people’s homes. It usually needs its own resolution and its own timeline.

Pricing both routes side by side lets council present a decision rather than a request. Your property manager or strata lawyer confirms which funding route your bylaws and provincial legislation actually permit — that part is not the same in every province.

4. Time it to the notice package

Most buildings approve this at an AGM or a special general meeting, which means the real deadline is not the meeting — it is the notice package that goes out weeks earlier. Costed options, resolution wording, and the supporting recommendation all have to exist before that mails.

Working backwards from the notice deadline is usually what determines whether this gets decided this year or next.

5. Put the reasoning on the record

Whatever council decides, document why. A written recommendation covering what was assessed, what was proposed, what it costs, and what it is expected to do for the insurance position protects the council either way. If the work goes ahead, it is the file that supports the spend. If it does not, it is the record that the risk was considered.

---

If it is useful, the building assessment we run ends with exactly that document — scoped costs, a phasing plan, both funding routes priced, and a written recommendation — at no cost and with no obligation to proceed.